Sign In
Sharjah Chamber Award for Innovators Judging Criteria Form
Judge Name  
Student Group Number  
Kindly note:
Weight out of 10:
Poor: (0 to 5 points)
Average: (6 to 7 points)
Excellent: (8 to 10 points)
Weight out of 20:
Poor: (0 to 10 points)
Average: (11 to 15 points)
Excellent: (16 to 20 points)

SECTION 1: POWERPOINT SLIDES (70%)

Criteria Weight Score
Problem Provide a clear explanation of the problem or customer need that you have identifie 10
Solution Provide an explanation of the innovative or sustainable idea/prototype/product solution 20
Unique Value Proposition Explain what makes your idea/prototype/product different from what existing competitors off 10
Business Model Explain your business model by specifically focusing on:
  • a. Customers: who are your customers?
  • b. Revenue: how do you intend to make money
20
Conclusion Close your presentation with a memorable and convincing pitch of your idea. 10

SECTION 2: PRESENTATION SKILLS & PROTOTYPE FIDELITY (30%)

Criteria Weight Score
Presentation Skills The skills you need in delivering effective and engaging presentations to a variety of audiences (UBC, n.d.) 20
Prototype Fidelity Fidelity refers to how the prototype conveys the look-and-feel of the final product (basically its level of detail and realism) (Babich, 2017). 10
Total